Sameer Khadka

Back to blogs

A Stoic Way to Handle Criticism

Criticism is something we encounter almost every day. It often stays with us longer than praise. Kind words can fade by evening, but one sharp remark can follow us to bed. I have noticed this in myself more often than I would like to admit.

Why do we give so much weight to what others say about us? Sometimes, it is not the words themselves that bother us, but the story we build around them afterward. We replay the conversation, question the person's intentions, and give those words more meaning than they may deserve. I explored this idea in Trapped by the Story.

What the Stoics Noticed

Epictetus, one of the great Stoic teachers, put it simply: people are disturbed not by things, but by their opinions about things. A remark is just a few words. Whether it becomes an insult, a lesson, or nothing at all depends on the judgment we attach to it.

This is the core of Stoic thinking. Some things are within our control, and others are not. What another person thinks or says about us is not up to us. How we respond is.

Marcus Aurelius prepared for this every morning. He reminded himself that he would meet people who were ungrateful, arrogant and unkind that day. None of them, he wrote, could harm his character unless he allowed it.

None of this means pretending criticism does not matter. As I wrote in Detachment Is Not Indifference, stepping back is not the same as not caring. The aim is to recognize what is worth learning from the criticism without allowing its emotional sting to control us.

Three Questions to Ask When Criticized

When criticism comes, our first instinct is often to defend ourselves. But perhaps we should pause and ask three questions before reacting.

  • Is it true? If it is, even partly, there may be something worth learning. Epictetus even suggested responding to criticism by considering that if the person knew all our other faults, they might have mentioned those too.
  • Is it mine to carry? Sometimes criticism says more about the person giving it than about us. We see ourselves partly through the eyes of others, but not every reflection is accurate.
  • Would this matter if no one were watching? Sometimes the sting comes from worrying about how others now see us. We become concerned with our reputation and our standing among the crowd. Remove that audience, and the answer often becomes clearer: correct what is true, let go of the rest, and keep moving.

Criticism can offer us an opportunity to learn, but only if we look beyond the emotions it brings. We do not have to accept every opinion, nor do we have to reject every uncomfortable remark. The next time someone criticizes you, take a moment before reacting. Look for what might be true, learn what you can, and let the rest go. What matters is not what was said, but how thoughtfully you choose to respond.